Opinion | This Is Un-American


new video loaded: This Is Un-American

transcript

transcript

This Is Un-American

A lot has happened this week. The New York Times Opinion editor Kathleen Kingsbury highlights one thing you shouldn’t miss: After President Trump tried to send the National Guard into Portland, Ore., a federal judge blocked him. Watch Kingsbury explain why the president’s actions defy the fundamental principles of the U.S. Constitution.

A lot has happened this week. “He addressed a ceasefire deal.” “Protesters outside of the ICE building.” “Government shutdown. No end in sight.” “Attorney General Letitia James has been indicted.” Here’s one thing you shouldn’t miss. At some point this year, you’ve probably seen President Trump send troops into Democratically led cities against the wishes of state and local officials. Then he set his sights on Portland, Oregon to quell a longstanding protest outside of an ICE facility even though in the days leading up to the order, fewer than 20 people were participating in the protest each night. “As of right now, there’s only about a dozen protesters.” What do these protests look like? “One hop this time.” “How ridiculous, the notion that we are violent.” Federal officers describe these protests as “low energy.” And how was Portland affected by these small protests? And so Portland sued President Trump. And last week, a federal judge appointed by Trump himself blocked the use of the Oregon National Guard. The judge said President Trump’s decision was untethered to facts and likely violated the Constitution. President Trump, however, found a workaround. He sent National Guardsmen from California into Oregon. The judge wasn’t having it. The next day, she called an emergency hearing where she blocked President Trump from using National Guardsmen from any state. Trump has been furious at the reaction to his orders. So why does any of this matter? By trying to get around this judge’s order, President Trump is chipping away at democracy on two crucial levels. First, the president is defying the judiciary, which is designed to be a check on executive power. And second, President Trump is using the military to go after American citizens he sees as his political opponents. And President Trump is going about this in a fundamentally un-American way. Remember, one of the reasons that the American Revolution was fought was because King George III decided to send troops into British colonies. The king was also doing this to quell dissent. So when they won, the founding fathers made sure to enshrine in the Constitution a high level of states’ rights, free speech, and the principle of civilian control over the military. At the end of the day, the president alone doesn’t get to decide when he uses the military against his own people. And if the courts say no, he must listen. That’s the American way.

A lot has happened this week. The New York Times Opinion editor Kathleen Kingsbury highlights one thing you shouldn’t miss: After President Trump tried to send the National Guard into Portland, Ore., a federal judge blocked him. Watch Kingsbury explain why the president’s actions defy the fundamental principles of the U.S. Constitution.

By Kathleen Kingsbury and Stephanie Shen

October 11, 2025

Kathleen Kingsbury and Stephanie Shen

Related Posts

Opinion | We Should Expect More From Our Supreme Court

I have friends who call it “opinionpalooza.” That time in June, the Supreme Court makes a mad dash toward the end of the term, scrambling to hand down all remaining…

Opinion | Your Summer 2026 Politics Quiz Is Here

Well, guys, it’s time to relax, have some summer fun, obsess about sports and, of course, contemplate all our national adventures in the world of politics. Which might not be…

You Missed

Initial US-Iran agreement leaves many key issues to be negotiated

  • By admin
  • June 17, 2026
  • 1 views
Initial US-Iran agreement leaves many key issues to be negotiated

Sam Bankman-Fried’s pardon bid faces bipartisan pushback in Congress: ‘Keep him locked up’

Sam Bankman-Fried’s pardon bid faces bipartisan pushback in Congress: ‘Keep him locked up’

Speakers in Ecuador’s Andes Blend Spanish With Kichwa

Speakers in Ecuador’s Andes Blend Spanish With Kichwa

Opinion | We Should Expect More From Our Supreme Court

Opinion | We Should Expect More From Our Supreme Court

Russian warship fires warning shots near UK-registered yacht in Channel

  • By admin
  • June 16, 2026
  • 6 views
Russian warship fires warning shots near UK-registered yacht in Channel

Anthropic’s IPO pitch has a new problem: The government can shut it down

Anthropic’s IPO pitch has a new problem: The government can shut it down